Had the joy of ordering lunch, which also turned into dinner, here today for the first time. All in all, a good experience.
I ordered a large jalapeno popper pizza, pepperoni rolls, and a brownie. You can order by the slice here. I imagine they offer that since they are located next to an industrial hub outside of town. They probably get a lot of walk-in customers from.nearby business looking for a quick bite.
The best part of my order were the pepperoni rolls. They were quite delish. They were crispy on the outside, and fluffy with gooey cheese on the inside. The seasoning on the outside added some flavor and they have several dipping sauces to choose from. I asked for marinara, and I really liked it. It's pretty sweet, which is how I like it.
The jalapeno popper pizza was decent. It is pretty straightforward, a cheese blend, jalapenos, bacon, and cream cheese make up the toppings. I don't want to dog on it a whole lot, because as a stand alone pie, it's fine. But when I compare it to the jalapeno popper pizza I get at Charm Pizza in Charm, Ohio....It doesn't compare.
A little crunch would really spruce it up a bit. What makes the pizza at Charm Pizza really stand out is they put crispy onion straw on it. Really adds another layer of flavor and that crunch gives it texture.
Something to think about if The Pizza Company checks these reviews.
The brownies were tasty. Brownies are hard to judge. Because you can honestly get pretty good brownies from a box if you bake them properly. Getting 2 for $1.50, I think that was the price, I feel is a good value if you are grabbing something sweet with your lunch on a break from work.
And the $30~ I spent felt fair. I think it's a good value for the quality and amount of food you get. The only other thing I would want is on large pizzas, cut them into squares. Cause the pieces on a large pie are rather massive. Makes it hard for people who don't eat a lot in one sitting.
But truthfully, this was a delightful lunch all around and a fair price. I'm full and I still have lunch for tomorrow from it after eating on it all day today.
One other thing to note. The location looks like a shack on the outside. But inside, it's actually a nice little place to sit down and eat. Really like the tables and just the overall look/vibe of the place.
Will I be back? Maybe. It's a ways out of my way to get there. But I think it's worth the trip.
Edit: Decided to try a more traditional pizza from here yesterday. I ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza.
The pizza is fine. But they seemed really light on the mushrooms. It reminded me of what old Domino's used to be like before their big rebrand 15-20 years ago.
Idk, I didn't hate it. But I didn't love it. Probably just gonna stick with Scotty's when I'm ordering pizza in the Mansfield area. It's more unique and they are more generous with their toppings.
Probably 4.75 Star food. This place is in the perfect place surrounded by businesses. They cater to the working women and men. The hours are perfect. Extremely nice people working there. Small parking lot.
I ordered a large NY white cheese pepperoni pizza. The first one I ever had and it was excellent 👍. I would say give it a try. The pizza was good. Don't be takin back by the location it's in a industrial park. 9am to 6:30 pm closed on weekends. I felt at home. Definitely I recommend it
Went in for the 2nd time. Very friendly family atmosphere. The pizza and cheese bread that we got were delicious. They have a wide variety of options. We got the Supreme pizza and cheese bread.
Reply from The Pizza Company
2025.05.01
Thank you, Karen! We're thrilled you enjoyed the pizza and pepperoni rolls and felt welcomed in our family atmosphere. We can't wait to see you again and hope you get to try more of our delicious options next time! 😊
Out-of-towners working seven minutes from The Pizza Company, so this will be an incomplete scouting report.
We ordered the Loaded Baked Potato pizza and it was damn good. Look great. Tasted great.
I almost feel bad only giving a 4/5 because I feel like after half a dozen visits, I'd be convinced of it being a 5/5. The crust is as good as pizza crust gets