Completely unreliable. We called and spoke to the host Matthew, asked for a table of 9, for the next day. He said they would accommodate us if we walked in. We made sure to ask him at least twice if he was sure as it was an office birthday and did not want to keep everyone waiting. We walked in the next day to find the rest. closed for a private party. Ruined our night. Not going back
Employees were friendly but didn't really return to check on us. My lobster roll was to have melted butter there definitely was no butter. But the lobster was very fresh. Very good brownie sundae.
Reply from P.J. Clarke's
2025.12.03
Hi Tina, thank you for sharing your experience. We're glad you enjoyed the lobster and brownie sundae, but we’re sorry to hear about the service and the missing butter. We appreciate you bringing this to our attention and would love the chance to follow up. Please feel free to contact us directly at thepjclarkes@gmail.com.
Food excellent server was attentive atmosphere was of a busy vibrant bar restaurant, we always visit here when in New York
Reply from P.J. Clarke's
2025.12.01
Thank you, Lance! We’re happy to hear you enjoyed the food, service, and vibrant atmosphere. It means a lot that you make us a regular stop when visiting New York. We look forward to welcoming you back again soon!
Excellente cuisine (lobster roll connecticut), service efficace et très courtois. Servi en terrasse avec une vue très sympa.
Reply from P.J. Clarke's
2025.07.08
Thank you for the kind words, Olivier! We’re glad you enjoyed the food and the view. We’ll be sure to pass your compliments along to the team!
Good everyday chain restaurant option. Midrange prices, ordinary food, decent service. Convenient but nothing special.
Reply from P.J. Clarke's
2025.11.11
Thank you for your feedback, Nancy! We’re happy you enjoyed the convenience and service, and we’ll keep working to make sure your next visit stands out for all the right reasons.
I came in yesterday around 4 to grab a beer and some food. I sat at the bar and Shaun/Shawn my bartender was fantastic. He really made me feel at home. It’s hard to keep good help these days I hope Shaun is well taken care of!
5stars
Reply from P.J. Clarke's
2025.11.11
Carter, thank you for the feedback! We are happy you had a great experience at P.J. Clarke's. Looking forward to welcoming you back soon!
Had a bite and drinks with a friend and it was lovely. Service was amazing and a special cheers to the flirtini made by the amazing bartender Sean!
Reply from P.J. Clarke's
2025.11.11
Kelsey, thank you for the feedback! We are happy you had a great experience at P.J. Clarke's. Looking forward to welcoming you back soon!
Una comida bastante buena, el servicio rapido y bueno, el personal muy atento, nos gusto la comida, no tan frito y grasiento como encontramos en muchos sitios similares, tienen una terraza y los platos suficientemente grandes
Reply from P.J. Clarke's
2025.11.10
Nicoleta, thank you for the feedback! We are happy you had a great experience at P.J. Clarke's. Looking forward to welcoming you back soon!