Carlo's Bakery Reviews 2025 | Trustindex.io

Write a review

Reviews

4.1 | 12160 total

5 stars

5501 pcs

4 stars

2060 pcs

3 stars

1203 pcs

2 stars

589 pcs

1 star

664 pcs

Source filter

10017 pcs

Verified

Jeremy Ridenour 2025.12.14

The cheese cake my be the best I've ever had. The cannolis were good too

Useful Report

Barbara Delia 2025.12.14

What a nice group of people. The service was excellent. Brownies moist and delicious

Useful Report

Francesca Schelotti 2025.12.12

Posto iconico per chi guardava la serie, i dolci sembrano molto buoni e belli, purtroppo nessuna opzione vegana

Useful Report

George Wines 2025.12.12

Best cannolis I've had in NYC. Staff was awesome.

Useful Report

Andrea Guerra Gomes de Sousa 2025.12.11

Bom como sempre. Encontramos a Grace que foi super simpática com a gente. Mesas para sentar e vitrine enorme com delícias. Loja mais tranquila do que a localizada na Times Square.

Useful Report

Brooklynn Oxendine 2025.12.11

Useful Report

Emily Baltodano 2025.12.11

No me parece una experiencia inolvidable, la comida no es especial, sabe muy comercial… pero hay mucha variedad y el servicio es rapido. La cafetería vale más por la nostalgia de los que vieron el show que por lo que ofrecen en gastronomía

Useful Report

Roger Flores 2025.12.09

Useful Report

Nick Brown 2025.12.09

Great canolis.

Useful Report

Nicolas Dantomio 2025.12.09

Terribly overprice, 11$ for a small " cheesecake" that is not a cheesecake at all, it's another kind of pastries but definitely not a cheesecake. Muffin are tasteless and very dry, 7$. You can eat way better muffin in supermarket.

Useful Report

Joy Burford 2025.12.07

Absolutely great!!! I’ve always wanted to go and yesterday I made it!!!!

Useful Report

Karen Gonzalez 2025.12.07

Useful Report

Jenneffer Vazquez 2025.12.06

Heaven wrapped in perfect crispy little rolls. I got two cannolis (one for now, one for later) and my son got a ginger bread man and gingerbread man iced latte which he likes. Service was efficient, polite and executed correctly. We got here right before the crowd did so we were lucky to grab seats and enjoy our yummy treats. Made my New York bucket list trip complete.

Useful Report

Kelly St-pierre 2025.12.05

I just buy a piece of cake at walmart in Canada this is the Best cake i eat of all my life am 45 i try 2 mix of cake they was delicious i was soo obsed about it i go back to walmart and i buy 12 piece of cake for myself i no am not raisonable . .if i visit new york i will go visit them after i see the show long time ago i wish i can taste it and finaly the cake came to my local walmart in Canada thank you

Useful Report