Verified Company
My experience at this barbershop was very disappointing. The trimmer used for my beard was not working properly and caused a lot of pain during shaving. The barber seemed impatient and his attitude was quite harsh and unfriendly. Overall, it was a very unpleasant experience, and I would not recommend this place.
Reply from Magic Hat Barber Shop
2025.11.10
Moahmed, We don't think you left your review for the correct barber shop. We do not have record of any visit by you to our shop and we would welcome the opportunity to assist you in sorting this out. Please give us a call: 317-663-9413 or message us through our website so we can help you!
It’s true—you get what you pay for. I recently moved to Carmel, and the first time I needed a haircut, I went to a local Sports Clips, which ended up being a hack job, to say the least. About three weeks later, I knew I needed to find someone who could fix the mess, and that’s when I found Magic Hat Barbershop.
I booked an appointment with Faith, and not only did she fix the disaster, but she completely exceeded my expectations. The shop is immaculately clean, the staff is friendly and professional, and the entire experience makes you feel like you’re getting a true VIP treatment.
More often than not, I leave a stylist feeling like I looked better before I walked in, but this place did the exact opposite—I left feeling like I was looking my best. Highly recommend!
Reply from Magic Hat Barber Shop
2025.09.02
Thank you! ✨💈
I've been going to the same barber for about 12 years but he recently moved to a shop about an hour away. I was a bit anxious to try out a new place after so long, but I booked with Faith and she absolutely knocked it out of the park. She just asked me a few questions about what I wanted to do with my hair and beard and then absolutely crushed it, all while having a nice convo and creating a chill vibe. The music here is also great, which is a nice touch. Almost seems too good to be in Indiana, but I'm glad it is! A great haircut and experience is worth paying a premium imo. This is how you present yourself to the world - skimp elsewhere!
Reply from Magic Hat Barber Shop
2024.04.17
Thank you Jared! ✨💈
Justin's Magic Hat is another reason to love New York. After the pandemic ran this Barber Extraordinaire out of NYC, he found his way to the heart of downtown Carmel. And am I glad he did! I am now officially a former Great Clips customer and a Magic Hat customer for life. Spend a little more, feel 10x better about how you look walking out. Never mind how much easier well cut hair is to manage on your own between cuts. Bye-bye clippers...hello magic scissors coming out of the Magic Hat and into the very talented hands of this true hairstyle artist. I predict the Magic Hat Barber Shop will become a downtown Carmel icon by by Christmas 2022. P.S. - I did not know Justin or anyone who did when he cut my hair for the first time on November 13, 2021.
Reply from Magic Hat Barber Shop
2021.11.14
😆✨💈Thank you!!
The best barber shop in the Indianapolis area. I found Magic Hat in a Current Carmel article. He has the best products and hands down the best haircuts. The environment is extremely clean and friendly. I highly recommend you going here.
Reply from Magic Hat Barber Shop
2023.09.12
Thanks Cole! ✨💈
