American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry Reviews

Carissa 2025.05.09

     

Highly recommend this place. The pawn shop was going to give me $175 for a necklace I had and i decided to check this place out and am very happy that i did because they gave me $580!!!!

Useful Report

Ashlynn Parks 2025.05.08

     

My favorite place to go to sell my jewelry !

Useful Report

D Rohr 2025.05.08

     

Though they did give me a fair price for the silver weight of my coins, (approx 250 coins) however they did not check any for their years and mint marks. My coins ranged between 1905 thru 1964, dimes, quarters, half dollars, various silvee dollars, and various 1 Troy ounce coins. The various dollars and 1 ounce coins being in mint cindition. That being said, they did pay me on the spot, and were friendly and acted professionally. I would recommend them.

Useful Report

Aaron Weaver 2025.05.02

     

Frank and Anna strike me as fair, knowledgeable, and honest. I will return to them for any of my gold needs!

Useful Report

Tony Martin 2025.04.28

     

Great place! They are knowledgeable, pleasant, honest, and quick.

Useful Report

Manny Fresh 2025.04.27

     

First time coming to American Rare Coin to try n sell my silver I had and to see what kind of a price they'd quote me. After a quick weight and purity check, the younger guy working there gave me a real reasonable offer for what I brought in and I accepted. Left with cash in my pocket and a happy new customer. This is a great place that won't rip you off unlike other stores (pawn shops). I'll definitely be back next time I need to sell any precious metals or coins. Thanks!

Useful Report

Reply from American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry 2025.05.08

hello Manny, thanks for this great review.

Heidi Lynn 2025.04.24

     

Great experience with Anna! I was selling coins for my uncle and very pleased with the offer. $old!

Useful Report

Reply from American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry 2025.05.08

thanks for the great review.

Maria Chavez Pringle 2025.04.24

     

They are amazing!! I have had the best service experience with them. Fair and professional.

Useful Report

Reply from American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry 2025.05.08

thanks for the great review.

Dwight Donaldson 2025.04.23

     

Great place..Quick and excellent service. Would highly recommend if you have any gold or coins that you want to sell or buy.

Useful Report

Reply from American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry 2025.04.24

thank you.

K Konrad 2025.04.19

     

Great prices and kind! We had a bit of trouble with a bank being dumb with our check we received from American Rare, but American Rare came through for us and made sure we were taken care of. 5 stars for sure. We traveled far to have a good experience, and it was worth it.

Useful Report

Reply from American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry 2025.04.24

great to meet you, thanks for taking the time to let p[eolple know about arc.

Thomas G McDaniel 2025.04.18

     

We brought in some coins to this establishment, not having much of any knowledge and the nice person that helped us out walked us through every single step explained pricing and we walked away with a pretty decent amount of money. Overall experience was amazing. Highly recommend. Thank you you guys.!

Useful Report

Reply from American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry 2025.04.19

thanks for the great review.

Nathan Dyson 2025.04.17

     

Had a great experience selling with the owner- he was polite and courteous, and ultimately gave me a great price on some silver I was looking to sell at the time. I would definitely come back!

Useful Report

Reply from American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry 2025.05.08

thank you

Eug 2025.04.17

     

Bought some silver eagle coins today. Great price and service. Very kind and professional staff. Thanks so much!!

Useful Report

Reply from American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry 2025.05.08

thank you

Averie Rivera 2025.04.15

     

amazing prices

Useful Report

Laura White 2025.04.08

     

I found them very fair in price. Very professional. I'd recommend their services to anyone interested in selling their silver. Thank you for the wonderful service.

Useful Report

Trace Brown 2025.04.03

     

I walked in with a box of old coins with no appointment. The staff immediately sat down with me and evaluated everything I had. They gave me a clear explanation whenever I had a question, and referenced publications when necessary. Excellent experience.

Useful Report

Paul Skipworth 2025.04.01

     

Anna Pike was very helpful. Wonderful place to do business.

Useful Report

Justin Hinh 2025.03.31

     

It technically qualifies as a coin shop, but barely. There were only four displays of coins and very little selection. It's more of a bullion shop. The dealer was friendly and shared some insights on the local coin shops in the area.

Useful Report

Reply from American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry 2025.04.03

thanks for the review, we are constantly changing the inventory from having thousands of silver oz to having only a few hundred. with the crazy amount of buying going on please call ahead and confirm your order.

Lisa Mahoney 2025.03.26

     

I have used their services a few times over the last couple of years, and find them to be knowledgeable and efficient. I'm not a collector, so I appreciate that they take the time to explain things. I have felt that I was getting a fair price for items I brought in.

Useful Report

Reply from American Rare Coin, Gold & Jewelry 2025.03.31

thanks for the review

Chelsea Bos 2025.03.21

     

They are AMAZING!!!!

Useful Report