Toledo Coin Exchange Reviews

Brett & crew are a huge asset to the precious metals industry! I would recommend them for all of your gold and silver needs. Long time veterans in this business. Highly recommended!

Cool place

Great place to buy a Lil silver

Fantastic experience! They told me one of my silver coins were worth more than I thought! Very honest folks that work there!!

Go there to sell your gold or silver jewelry. They have the prices

Friendly, Professional, and Fair.

Polite and good staff but they use just 1 source for silver spot price and it is always the lowest price, then they reduce the price even more for hire amounts of silver. So it’s always better to sell 1 oz over anything 2 oz and up. Doesn’t really make sense. When I went and sold silver it was spotted at 31 and some change from 10 different sources. But the source they use had silver at 30. I know it’s not a crazy difference but when you’re selling a lot of silver at once it adds up.

This company has always treated me very fair and I think they are very honest. I've been to other places around to sell gold & silver but Toledo coin exchange is by far the only place I'll go for my gold & silver.

If you’re looking to sell coins or gold this place gives you top dollar then another pawnshop

Great service! Fair prices!

👍🏿👍🏿

Best place in Toledo for gold and silver sales

Excellent knowledge and service + highly ethical and fair.

I was interested to visit Toledo Coin again after getting the former PCGS president as the new owner; I'd had some bad experiences there before after being brushed off, talked down to, and not taken seriously. Unfortunately, nothing had changed. The counter guy that I ended up with immediately assumed I didn't know what I was talking about. He didn't look at any of the dates on my coins or ask anything about them before just banging his finger into them one by one telling me "this one is worth 7 cents; this is a $1". When I even asked him to take a look at the collar error on one of the wheat cents he proceeded to mansplain to me how coins are made and collar errors occur! If I KNOW it's a collar error, why are you trying to dumb down and teach me? OH, so you could tell me how it really wasn't worth anything! Literally every single coin I had (those that he deigned to look at) was, to him, "just not a market for it". meanwhile, the exact same coin I had was in the display right where they were selling it for $125!!! Is it because I'm a numiswomatic? Or just sleezy low-balling to pay the least amount possible? Either way, horrible treatment. Again. TIP: If you update your website to say you buy all these coins, so I come in with one of the lowest mintage rarest variable of that coin, and I hear how it's worthless, MAYBE TAKE IT OFF THE WEBSITE AS SOMETHING YOU BUY. Besides, I know exactly how much that coin is worth - always test your dealers!! Know exactly what you have so when you walk in there and get this dismal nonsense you know to W.A.L.K. O.U.T.

New owner, same great personal service with a smile. Called other places before I went… Great rates on Gold. Would go again. Highly recommend.